Olimometer 2.47

    Statement: “We have the lowest number of square footage of library space in our district,” David Alvarez, one of seven San Diego City Council District 8 candidates, said at a San Ysidro candidates forum March 31.

    Determination: False

    Analysis: Alvarez, a staffer for state Sen. Denise Ducheny, D-San Diego, is vying to replace outgoing Council President Ben Hueso as councilman for District 8, which represents the city’s southernmost neighborhoods. So far, Alvarez is the campaign’s money leader.

    At a San Ysidro forum last week, he offered more statistics than any other candidate. The library stat, among others, was used to illustrate his point that the city doesn’t provide District 8 with enough services.

    Five months ago, Alvarez would have been right when he compared library space in District 8 to other districts. Not now.

    In December, the city opened a new $13.7 million, 25,000-square foot library in Logan Heights that replaced a 4,000-square foot branch.

    The new branch increased library space in District 8 by more than 90 percent to 44,048 square feet. That put District 8 ahead of Districts 3 and 7.

    In response, Alvarez acknowledged that the opening of the Logan Heights branch boosted District 8 out of last place.

    “While that’s a great starting point, our communities in District 8 still have only three branch libraries, which is the fewest of all the council districts despite increased demand from our residents to uses facilities like this,” Alvarez said.

    In case you’re wondering, Alvarez is right that District 8 does have the fewest number of libraries.

    Here is the ranking of library square footage by council district, according to numbers confirmed by city officials:

    • District 2: 194,676 (Note: District 2 includes the 150,000-square foot main library).
    • District 1: 85,414
    • District 5: 78,950
    • District 6: 60,676
    • District 4: 49,173
    • District 8: 44,048
    • District 7: 36,827
    • District 3: 35,042

    If you disagree with our determination or analysis, please express your thoughts in the comments section of this blog post. Explain your reasoning.

    You can also e-mail new Fact Check suggestions to factcheck@voiceofsandiego.org. What claim should we explore next?



      This article relates to: Fact Check

      As a member-supported nonprofit, VOSD relies on on people like you. Please donate.

      Written by Summer Polacek

      Summer is the Development Manager at Voice of San Diego. You can contact her at summer@voiceofsandiego.org or 619.550.5667.


      Help VOSD Raise $100k by Dec. 31

      As a member-supported nonprofit, we rely on your donation to keep this service going. Will you donate today?


      Log In or Register

      Registered users can follow narratives, comment on articles, check donation history and more.

      If you’ve never logged in before, please create a free account. If you’re a VOSD member, please use the email address associated with your donations.

      Forgot Password?