Donate Now Learn more about member benefits
Beau Lynott, a VOSD contributor:
What it should not be is a commercialized space, for Starbucks or any other private vendor. There are plenty of urban planners and landscape architects that would be happy to volunteer ideas for the plaza. Maybe seating areas with potted plants/temporary landscaping. Something that allows people to congregate and can be cleared for events.
If there is going to be a commercial presence, it should be a local one. I would love to see outdoor furniture, plants, performance spaces, etc., along with cafes and food stalls, even if only temporary (what about a corner of the plaza where we can have a food truck rotation?). But no Starbucks – it isn’t even good coffee.
Amy Roth, who originally suggested the “Starbucks Central” idea:
Obviously I didn’t mean “Starbucks” literally! I meant it as a metaphor for a comfy home-away-from home-like setting where you could have a snack or drink, read a book or newspaper or electronic device, meet friends even! Any of the ideas that have been submitted would be terrific in my opinion.
Randy Dotinga, a VOSD contributor:
New York City’s Bryant Park would be a good model … many small tables with chairs where people can work, soak up the sun or chat, plus a few food vendors. As for Starbucks: They have air conditioning, reliable wi-fi and (sometimes) comfy chairs. It’s hard to find an independent coffeehouse with all three, at least in SD. I’ve been to almost all of them (such is the fate of a work-at-home type) and can think of one that meets all those criteria.
Don Wood :
The ferry piers in Tiburon, Calif., comes to mind. Every weekend, they put out tables and a local restaurant serves people breakfast on the pier. It’s very popular with the locals and people come on the ferry from all over the Bay Area to eat there. The key would be for the city to select the right restaurant operator to team up with a local coffee shop operator to activate the plaza. This option should be looked at as part of city’s staff’s own study of the space.
The key for me would be to ensure that nothing permanently be placed in the view corridor along the length of El Prado.
What is it about California that makes us allergic to open space?
Maybe we should take a closer look at the Piazza San Marcos in Venice, the Zócalo in Mexico City, or (dare I say it) Red Square in Moscow for inspiration. All of these are powerful cultural landmarks made up of mostly empty space.
Why not create something truly unique to San Diego? Hardscape materials now exist that clean the air when exposed to sunlight, and are self-cleaning. Use those materials to create a “picture” when seen from the air and patterns on the ground. Inscribe on those pavers “dreams” in pictographs or words. Install a QR code and number that links to a database holding information about the author of the dream and additional information. Make Balboa Park’s plazas and walkways one big canvas for the public. If the pavers are made of interlocking design, “locked” to a grid underneath, and allow for water to percolate between them, the “picture” created by the colored pavers could be changed to match an annual theme for the park. How to pay for it? A “Donations for A Dream” campaign.
“Hardscape” on a grid that has electrical, water, and sewage connections running underneath that could be accessed as necessary for events and activities.
Balboa Park was built as a “City of Dreams” in 1915. Why not truly make it one?
Use of a grid underneath the paving system would allow for removable growing sections as part of the changing landscape of dreams.
Comments have been lightly edited for clarity. See anything in there we should fact check? Tell us here.
Lisa Halverstadt is a reporter for Voice of San Diego and Dagny Salas is the web editor. You can reach them directly at email@example.com and firstname.lastname@example.org.
Voice of San Diego is a nonprofit that depends on you, our readers. Please donateto keep the service strong. Click here to find out more about our supporters and how we operate independently.
This article relates to:
Balboa Park, Community, News, Parks, Share