The city of San Diego received international acclaim in the 1990s for its approach to policing, thanks to a method that focused on preventing crime and building community trust rather than just responding to incidents. Shelley Zimmerman, who is expected to be approved as the city’s new chief Tuesday, knows about that legacy as much as anyone.
Before her ascension, Zimmerman served as assistant chief for neighborhood policing, a position created to manage the strategy, known as problem-oriented policing or community policing. That position saw her passing out candy at a Mount Hope YMCA’s Halloween party and touting the number of community meetings SDPD officers attend.
Zimmerman’s predecessor, William Lansdowne, focused on something else.
Lansdowne emphasized speedy response times. Under Lansdowne, SDPD analyzed a massive amount of crime data to deploy cops to probable hot spots. Lansdowne oversaw San Diego’s lowest crime rates in a half-century, but also let some policies to prevent officer misconduct and racial profiling fall by the wayside.
Deciding which approach to embrace will be one of the biggest decisions of Zimmerman’s tenure. Will she prioritize crime response like Lansdowne or crime prevention like the chiefs before him? (My old colleague Keegan Kyle shed great light on Lansdowne’s philosophy and SDPD’s history.)
Zimmerman was unavailable for an interview last week. A department spokesman said she plans to talk to the media soon. In the meantime, her statements on the department’s community policing record don’t offer much clarity.
Support Independent Journalism Today
Lansdowne did not preside over the lowest crime rate in San Diego. I've said this again and again on the news, and sent info to VOSA reporters. If you get the crime reports for the five years before Lansdowne and the year Lansdowne took office and five years thereafter, you will find a shocking reduction of crime time rate. But, as I've said over and over again, we learned in the jane Roe and jane Doe cases that the SDPD was required to UNDER REPORT crime so that it looked like crime was down. Don;t know how many more times I should have to inform the press of this - or maybe the press could just do the same CPRA request that I did....
Many departments require applicants to live in their city for one year prior to employment and remain a city resident as long as they serve. First and foremost, this allows background investigators to speak with neighbors and people that applicants interact with daily. Otherwise, background investigators only speak to their references, which are people that support the applicant. Living in the city also gives applicants a stake in their community. Most officers end up living far from SD and have no vested interest as it is not "their community." Statistically speaking, all departments struggle with bad apples. They exist in every organization. If you are a vested member of the community, seeing an officer behaving badly impacts you not only as a fellow officer, but also as a community member. It changes everything.
Cameras are being used in most departments. They benefit good officers and good people that interact with officers. They are not good for bad officers and bad people. It is a win win for everyone. This department really needs to make basic, fundamental changes in how they hire and follow their officers. They need to use technology to their advantage and look at how other departments obtain good police officers that are vested in their community. Finally, we cannot hire good officers if we are not competitive. They are some of the lowest paid in comparison to same size cities and departments. They use failing equipment and antiquated technology. All of the good applicants are going to get hired by departments that offer more than we do, it is simple decision making 101. If we are left with a bottom of the barrel applicant pool, we end up with bottom of the barrel officers, and that hurts everyone. It is time to get with the program and make this department a modern and competitive place to work.
A big Thank You to our new Police Chief Shelley Zimmerman.
Chief Zimmerman allowed $1 Million in funding for Police cameras transferred to the San Diego Housing Commission (SDHC) to keep both the Veterans and downtown Homeless Emergency Tents opened until the end of the Fiscal Year 2014 on June 30, 2014.
Very great start.