Image: trueStatement: “The NFL bylaws … prohibit public ownership (partial or otherwise) of NFL teams,” mayoral candidate Nathan Fletcher wrote in response to a VOSD survey published Dec. 8.

Determination: True

Analysis: The Chargers’ nearly decade-long search for a new stadium is expected to reach a turning point next year. The team and Mayor Jerry Sanders want to put a proposal on the November 2012 ballot.

They’re still hashing out the proposal’s details, but both have highlighted public subsidies as a major component of funding an estimated $800 million downtown stadium. Sanders’ spokesman told San Diego Newsroom last week that the public could be asked to pick up half the stadium’s bill.

With the stadium search heating up alongside the election to succeed Sanders, we asked the mayoral candidates to consider an idea from one of their competitors, Bob Filner. If the public provides subsidies for a stadium, Filner suggested at an Oct. 19 debate, it should get a share of the team’s ownership.

Of the election’s other high-profile candidates, Carl DeMaio and Bonnie Dumanis both avoided our question and instead described how they would generally negotiate with the Chargers.

But unlike his peers, Nathan Fletcher did respond directly to our question. He called Filner’s idea unrealistic.

“Bob Filner apparently failed to read the NFL bylaws, which prohibit public ownership (partial or otherwise) of NFL teams,” Fletcher wrote. “The Green Bay Packers are an exception, grandfathered in when the league was originally formed.”

The NFL’s rules don’t allow public ownership, partial or otherwise. Article III specifically prohibits ownership by any not-for-profit organization like local government.

NBC Sports recently examined the rule for another debate halfway across the country. The Minnesota Vikings are also seeking a new football stadium, and a state lawmaker suggested sharing ownership in exchange for public money.

NBC Sports put the scenario to NFL spokesman Greg Aiello, who responded, “It is not permissible under our ownership policies. There is no public ownership permitted.”

OK, but what about the Green Bay Packers, which recently sold stock to reduce borrowing for a $143 million stadium expansion? NBC Sports confirmed the background on that puzzler, too:

The Packers are publicly owned because they became publicly owned at a time when league rules permitted it. Besides, it would be hard for one person to go out and buy up all the stock. Under current rules, no public ownership is permitted, regardless of how much the majority owner retains.

Since Fletcher accurately cited the NFL’s rules, we’ve rated his statement True.

Before putting this idea completely to rest, however, it’s worth noting that rules can change. In 1997, for example, Major League Baseball started allowing public ownership on the condition that a private owner maintain a majority of the stock. The next year, the Cleveland Indians sold public shares and raised $60 million.

Keegan Kyle is a news reporter for voiceofsandiego.org. He writes about public safety and handles the Fact Check Blog. What should he write about next?

Please contact him directly at keegan.kyle@voiceofsandiego.org or 619.550.5668. You can also find him on Twitter (@keegankyle) and Facebook.

Follow @keegankyle

Follow @voiceofsandiego

Like VOSD on Facebook.

    This article relates to: Chargers Stadium, Fact Check, Government, News
    Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

    Stay up-to-date on stories like this. Sign up for a VOSD newsletter.

    Written by Keegan Kyle

    19 comments
    Will Dawson
    Will Dawson subscriber

    Public ownership would require outside auditing and a true window into how $ is made by the NFL The 1 % elite owners do not want that!

    Sandawg
    Sandawg

    Public ownership would require outside auditing and a true window into how $ is made by the NFL The 1 % elite owners do not want that!

    shawn fox
    shawn fox subscriber

    This fact check isn't very convincing. They quoted a bylaw prohibiting not-for-profit public ownership. What about for-profit ownership like a corporation? Is the team not allowed to be incorporated either?

    shawn1874
    shawn1874

    This fact check isn't very convincing. They quoted a bylaw prohibiting not-for-profit public ownership. What about for-profit ownership like a corporation? Is the team not allowed to be incorporated either?

    Will Dawson
    Will Dawson subscriber

    $ 1,000,000,000 bond issue without interest for 30 years is $ 34,000,000 a year!

    Sandawg
    Sandawg

    $ 1,000,000,000 bond issue without interest for 30 years is $ 34,000,000 a year!

    Will Dawson
    Will Dawson subscriber

    $ 1,000,000,000.00 gift to the Spanos! It can't be done and it won't be done so move on to the real world!

    Sandawg
    Sandawg

    $ 1,000,000,000.00 gift to the Spanos! It can't be done and it won't be done so move on to the real world!

    Bob Jones
    Bob Jones subscriber

    When politicians sit down with the big money boys anything can happen no matter how ludicrous it may seem to the citizenry.

    rwj5125
    rwj5125

    When politicians sit down with the big money boys anything can happen no matter how ludicrous it may seem to the citizenry.

    mlcred
    mlcred

    If you truly can't believe it you are very naive. Just look at the ballpark and convention center for previews.

    michael-leonard
    michael-leonard subscriber

    If you truly can't believe it you are very naive. Just look at the ballpark and convention center for previews.

    joshuajay619
    joshuajay619

    I wonder, with the state of the economy, if the NFL would consider the change that MLB made to allow minority ownership by public entities? Highly doubtful. But, that does sound nice.

    josepho858
    josepho858

    Comments by ibphotos and mathteacher are both true. Nothing to add except that what they say is completely valid!

    joseph olivas
    joseph olivas subscriber

    Comments by ibphotos and mathteacher are both true. Nothing to add except that what they say is completely valid!

    Edmund Deaton
    Edmund Deaton subscribermember

    Mr. Spanos can build any stadium he desires, provided he does it himself. It would be ethically wrong for citizens to give him money when there are a large number of homeless people sleeping on the streets. These people need our help. Mr. Spanos should get in line, he might even spend a night on the streets to see what a real welfare recipient needs.

    mathteacher
    mathteacher

    Mr. Spanos can build any stadium he desires, provided he does it himself. It would be ethically wrong for citizens to give him money when there are a large number of homeless people sleeping on the streets. These people need our help. Mr. Spanos should get in line, he might even spend a night on the streets to see what a real welfare recipient needs.

    robert lopo
    robert lopo subscriber

    Without a direct cut of the revenue from all sources of income generated at a stadium, investing in that stadium is a waste of money. Maybe we could convince the NFL to rely on room tax and trickle down sales tax to repay it's 400 million investment.

    ibphotos
    ibphotos

    Without a direct cut of the revenue from all sources of income generated at a stadium, investing in that stadium is a waste of money. Maybe we could convince the NFL to rely on room tax and trickle down sales tax to repay it's 400 million investment.


    ×

    Log In or Register

    Registered users can follow narratives, comment on articles, check donation history and more.

    If you’ve never logged in before, please create a free account. If you’re a VOSD member, please use the email address associated with your donations.

    Forgot Password?
    New to VOSD? Create an account

    ×
    Test Modal
    • Note: You cannot change your username.
    • Minimum length of 8 charactersStrength indicator

    ×
    Sign Up For the Morning Report and Top Stories

    Sign Up For the
    VOSD Morning Report

    Get San Diego’s top stories delivered to your inbox each morning.

    To stop this message from appearing, Log in or Register.

    ×