|
|
|
|
an independent nonprofit |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Myrland: I'm the Decider
Published: Monday, August 6, 2007 6:01 PM PDT
Wow, so apparently over the weekend, KPBS GM Doug Myrland unleashed on one of the public station's blogs. Myrland and the station have heard a fair share of complaints about the cancellation of the television show "Full Focus."
But the complaints, to me, don't seem to be just about "Full Focus." Ask any government official what happens when you cut services at the same time you announce that your revenues are going up.
People don't like that.
Well, the same thing basically happened at KPBS. Myrland undoubtedly has to make tough choices from time to time, but it's pretty unreasonable to expect that people aren't going to be rather upset when you cancel a service without providing either a replacement program or a plan to do so.
Yet Myrland let loose on the station's supporters this weekend.
Gloria Penner, the host of "Full Focus," had penned a little piece about the show's demise. Several readers responded below and they were joined by Myrland himself, who let out some frustration:
I don't know where people get the odd idea that we should survey members on every management decision we make. KPBS has been in existence for 46 years, and NEVER has it been a collective, or even a participatory democracy. I make decisions in the same way every General Manager before me did.
Readers seized on the contention Myrland made on the radio last week that, although the station wasn't losing money, the reason he had canceled "Full Focus" came out of an effort of "ordering the priorities" at the station.
It appears, though, that without a plan to replace the program, it was merely a service cut. One that came in spite of the fact that revenue has grown for the station.
And Myrland responded:
"Ordering the priorities" is a polite way of saying we wanted to get rid of under-performing activities in favor of things we thought would attract more viewers and listeners. Time will tell if we're right or wrong. Isn't that plain enough?
This process doesn't need to be "transparent." We aren't elected officials -- every budget line item and every personnel decision and every bit of information we collect is not everybody else's business. Just because you give a contribution or pay taxes doesn't give you the right to decide -- or even influence -- what goes on the air and what doesn't. Our audited financials are on the web site. Our [Corporation for Public Broadcasting] report is on the web site. I go on the air, and in this forum, to explain the major decisions we make. That's all the "transparency" that is required or appropriate.
Everybody is entitled to their opinion. But as I said on the radio, listeners and viewers get to decide only if they want to watch or to listen.
Myrland kept going and, eventually, this morning, he apologized.
First of all, I again apologize for my original post. I had come to the end of a very long and difficult week, and I was certainly inappropriately defensive and harsh. So I hope you'll accept my apologies.
But I still think -- the whole time he was going back and forth with readers -- that he missed the main point. The questions don't seem to be about "Full Focus" as much as the consternation over the fact that KPBS -- as Myrland says -- is not hurting financially. So why are they cutting the programs they previously offered?
He says they'll be doing newer, better stuff. He probably should have planned to say what that stuff will be if he wanted to avoid at least some of the consternation from supporters.
35 Comments so far on this story...
Reader feedback
- Users may post more than one comment, but should not pose as multiple users. Multiple posts from the same IP address but with a different user name on each will be reviewed to determine whether abuse has occurred.
- Posts with overly personal attacks or unsubstantiated allegations may be edited or deleted.
- Please be patient with the posts -- there may be a delay before they appear on the site -- and make sure to enter the code in the "image verification" box.
|
Scott Lewis on Politics
The Scott Lewis on Politics blog, abbreviated cleverly as SLOP, is a collection of observations, insights and the occasional scoop on public affairs in San Diego. Please feel free to e-mail Scott at scott.lewis@voiceofsandiego.org.
He insists the devastating blow dealt to his pension case wasn't the end. In fact, he called on the mayor and council to join in.
Monday, August 6 -- 3:51 pm
An analysis of Sunday’s elections by local experts.
Monday, August 6 -- 4:16 pm
What's in the former Tijuana mayor's tequila?
Monday, August 6 -- 3:30 pm
SURVIVAL IN SAN DIEGO
Some thoughts from the other side of the bill that would freeze HOA payments for affordable-unit buyers.
Friday, August 3 -- 5:42 pm
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
In years on the Board of Education, Ron Ottinger and I disagreed on many things, but neither of us was ever missing in action and we always cared deeply about shaping public education policy for the benefit of all children.
Monday, August 6 -- 1:29 pm
CAFÉ SAN DIEGO
If all Californians were required to limit their household trash to the 32-gallon trash can and recyclables to the 60-gallon bins, we can help change the way we all think about the trash we create.
Sunday, August 5 -- 9:14 pm
COMMENTARY: SLOP
The KPBS GM claims he has plenty of revenue but he cut his station's offerings with no real plan to replace them and he can't understand why people are mad.
Monday, August 6 -- 6:01 pm
COMMENTARY: RICH TOSCANO
San Diego home prices were still falling in May, according to the Case-Shiller Index
Friday, August 3 -- 9:26 am
|
|
|
|
This Just In
KPBS airs a segment about student testing and its discontents. » Dec. 1 -- 10:00 am
Get to know some San Diegans you never might have met.
Dec. 1 -- 9:59 am
Three out of the four new arrivals indicate they would have voted to save libraries and recreation centers.
Nov. 26 -- 5:22 pm
SURVIVAL IN SAN DIEGO
An update from Alan House, the cemetery manager who moonlights as a Christmas tree farmer.
Dec. 1 -- 3:12 pm
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
Again. ... libraries shouldn't be first to suffer at hands of city's budget crisis.
Dec. 1 -- 4:54 pm
CAFÉ SAN DIEGO
Nationally and locally, voters didn't just elect new governments on Nov. 4. They opened the door to new roles for government.
Nov. 25 -- 6:39 pm
COMMENTARY: SLOP
A quick point about that NYT article.
Dec. 1 -- 3:10 pm
COMMENTARY: RICH TOSCANO
Some more visuals on the latest Case-Shiller home price index release.
Nov. 28 -- 11:50 am
|
 |
|
|
|
Copyright © 2008 voiceofsandiego.org. All Rights Reserved.
|