voiceofsandiego.org: Slop... Not 'Be a Man'
an independent nonprofit |
We depend on your donations. Consider joining us today.

Not 'Be a Man'

Published: Friday, October 5, 2007 2:09 PM PDT



Reader Fed Up took me to task below my column Thursday and the point gives me an opportunity to expand. First off, here's most of the comment:

Wow, Scott, quite a column -- your call for Mayor Sanders to pull on his jackboots and "be a man." Be proud of cutting secret deals with developers who flaunt FAA rules? Be proud of affably fronting for behind-the-scenes corporate interests? Be proud of spiking the role and influence of community planning groups? Be proud of a hand-picked "committee" of lobbyists who are trying to change city charter rules and concentrate power in the unaccountable hands of a few? Be proud of side-stepping the real fiscal plight of this metropolis by turning a blind eye to the positives of declaring bankruptcy?

I think Fed Up misses my point. I don't think the mayor should be proud of bad things: I think he should only do things he can be proud of. Get it? He shouldn't initiate a discussion or proposal he will only want to run away from when we all start to talk about it. And if he can't be part of at least setting his staff in a certain direction according to principles that he should boldly communicate, he's got issues.

My point was that this system of government -- unlike the past -- won't allow him to let his staff cook up proposals from which he can distance himself if they become too hot to handle. He needs to realize this and embrace it.

This may sound simplistic, but much of the mayor's problem has resulted, I think, from this fantasy he had that he could somehow distance himself from (or hide) what his staff did. And so, every time we learned that he, in fact, was not so distant from that which he claimed to be it was a bigger deal than it needed to be.

-- SCOTT LEWIS




8 Comments so far on this story...

"Fed Up" sounds like Mike Aguirre!

Posted by Cynic | reply to this comment
October 5, 2007 1:22 pm

My recollection was that Sanders ran on the odd platform that he would be the figurehead and Fromann would do the work. It wasn't that he was dishonest...it was that he did exactly what he said he would do, and has only gotten into real trouble by trying to act mayoral when he lacks the necessary skills and dismisses informed staff. When Sanders was with the police department, he had competent subordinates who took care of the annoying details, but he has very few people on the mayoral staff (particularly now) who know how to run a city. Jay Goldstone cannot be everywhere, even if he has the abilities Sanders lacks. Sanders is not a bad man, but he is not acting in a smart manner when he places people in charge who don't know what they are doing and then fires anyone who disagrees with him.

Posted by Leanne1 | reply to this comment
October 5, 2007 1:52 pm

What I hear from people in the city is that staff is not asked to leave because they disagree with Mayor Sanders, but, rather, because they are not performing thier jobs effectively or successfully. The BPR process that Reynolds was responsible for is an exercise in futility with staff scurrying about, attending meetings and developing mythical performance standards just so it will look like something is being done. As for Wade, the Purchasing Depratment is in a shambles, a victim of the BPR, cut to a skeleton staff who cannot possibly process the hundreds of contracts that the City needs to do business. Sanders has reached the point that he needs to take the reins and stop being a puppet who allows others to pull his strings. Hear that, Fred?

Posted by Mishel | reply to this comment
October 5, 2007 3:52 pm

I wasn't talking about Reynolds and Wade when I referenced released informed staff. Not all staff that have left the City make the news, and I know several who left prematurely because of the dismissive attitude of Sanders and friends who seemed to think they know more than they do about staff jobs. I agree Purchasing is a victim of BPR, but it isn't the only department suffering from this poorly conceived idea. It went forward with Sanders' blessing and support so don't pretend he hasn't responsibility. Someone should ask, but never will, what the real costs of pulling hours and hours of staff time into doing BPR and the personnel revamping that are a direct result of Sanders making the decision to remake the City without really understanding how the City works. He has solved one problem. The City doesn't work like it used to.

Posted by Leanne1 | reply to this comment
October 5, 2007 5:00 pm

Fed Up is 100% correct, this City is Bankrupt. We will never dig out of the whole the gov welfare queens have dug for us. We should have declared BK 2 years ago, we already wasted the $100 million tobacco settlement money on the welfare queens, how much more will be wasted before we HAVE to declare BK????

Posted by Billy Bob Henry | reply to this comment
October 5, 2007 9:12 pm

One of the great values associated with clear assignment of power in government is that it requires effective leaders to "saddle up" as Scott explains, and take responsibility both for actions and ideas. It allows for clear assignment of blame and credit, and it lets an executive authority especially, have energy and initiative to attack specific issues. I also am disappointed with the continued slouching, bumbling attitude of the city government after the strong-mayor system's adoption. The Mayor and Council should operate with strength and confidence in their powers, and jocky for their preferred outcomes. That's how this sort of government is supposed to work. Playing around at the margins and pretending to be just a channel through which other staffers' ideas is just not how this system was designed. We changed it for a reason.

Posted by CP | reply to this comment
October 6, 2007 8:25 am

Scott -- In this era of corporate-style "accountability" that everyone touts, Mayor Jerry Sanders, friend-of-corporate- should have his feet held to the fire of accountability. Your column essentially notes that Sanders' mayoral performance has been a disaster, and you plaintively say, "he should only do things he can be proud of." You wish he would embrace the power of being "strong mayor" and use it wisely. Well, me too. That's electoral politics. But the apolitical ex-cop Jerry Sanders was purposely cultivated for this job ( with previous posts at Red Cross and United Way) and approved by the backroom cabal of Malin Burnham, John Moores, the Union-Tribune and the Labor Council -- incredible bedfellows! --who wanted an amiable go-along-get-along fella who would not interfere in their plans for re-making this city and its charter as they see (pro)fit. Sanders is a figurehead and needs to go.

Posted by Fed Up | reply to this comment
October 6, 2007 10:40 am

Please correct the omission on line 2 of my recent post to you: To read " ...Mayor Jerry Sanders, friend of corporate fixers, should have his feet held to the fire of accountability...." Thanks.

Posted by Fed Up | reply to this comment
October 6, 2007 3:14 pm


Reader feedback
  • Users may post more than one comment, but should not pose as multiple users. Multiple posts from the same IP address but with a different user name on each will be reviewed to determine whether abuse has occurred.
  • Posts with overly personal attacks or unsubstantiated allegations may be edited or deleted.
  • Please be patient with the posts -- there may be a delay before they appear on the site -- and make sure to enter the code in the "image verification" box.
Post a comment
Name:
Email:
Comments:
Current Word Count: Verification Code
8fb8df4

Scott Lewis on Politics

The Scott Lewis on Politics blog, abbreviated cleverly as SLOP, is a collection of observations, insights and the occasional scoop on public affairs in San Diego. Please feel free to e-mail Scott at scott.lewis@voiceofsandiego.org.

Booze Ban Moves On :

 

A council committee heard hours of testimony before forwarding options for a beach drinking ban to the full City Council.

Wednesday, October 10 -- 6:10 pm

Council Members Also Accepted:

 

A number of other politicians took campaign contributions from their employees, too.

Wednesday, October 10 -- 7:09 pm

Questioning the Editorial:

 

Two campaign law experts question whether the U-T's case against Aguirre would fly.

Wednesday, October 10 -- 4:17 pm


Sponsored By

MOST POPULAR STORIES:

SURVIVAL IN SAN DIEGO

County's Home Repos Skyrocket :

 

Bank repossessions swell 14-fold in September compared to a year ago.

Wednesday, October 10 -- 7:05 am

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

Tell Us What We Need to Hear:

 

Jonathan Kozol left me wanting more.

Tuesday, October 9 -- 2:09 pm

CAFÉ SAN DIEGO

Sunroad's Fault, Not Mike's:

 

But the city attorney did not work to resolve or minimize the problem that both he and the mayor inherited

Wednesday, October 10 -- 4:13 pm

COMMENTARY: SLOP

The Lawyers :

 

The U-T's well-planned grenade may be blowing up in the paper's face.

Wednesday, October 10 -- 5:11 pm

COMMENTARY: RICH TOSCANO

September Housing Supply and Demand :

 

The tightening mortgage market has caused an abrupt decline in home sales.

Tuesday, October 9 -- 10:54 am

Sponsored by

This Just In

School Testing Trouble on the Radio:

 KPBS airs a segment about student testing and its discontents. » Dec. 1 -- 10:00 am



The Beautiful People:

 Get to know some San Diegans you never might have met.

Dec. 1 -- 9:59 am


Incoming Council Members Weigh In on Budget Decision:

 Three out of the four new arrivals indicate they would have voted to save libraries and recreation centers.

Nov. 26 -- 5:22 pm


SURVIVAL IN SAN DIEGO

41 Trees in Three Days:

 An update from Alan House, the cemetery manager who moonlights as a Christmas tree farmer.

Dec. 1 -- 3:12 pm



LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

Testing Trumps Teaching:

 Assessments are necessary but classroom teachers should determine which assessments to use.

Nov. 25 -- 7:55 pm



CAFÉ SAN DIEGO

Voters Value Good Government:

 Nationally and locally, voters didn't just elect new governments on Nov. 4. They opened the door to new roles for government.

Nov. 25 -- 6:39 pm



COMMENTARY: SLOP

Our Audience:

 A quick point about that NYT article.

Dec. 1 -- 3:10 pm



COMMENTARY: RICH TOSCANO

Home Price Chartfest:

 Some more visuals on the latest Case-Shiller home price index release.

Nov. 28 -- 11:50 am


Copyright © 2008 voiceofsandiego.org. All Rights Reserved.