voiceofsandiego.org: Cafesandiego... 'A Simple, Practical Solution'
an independent nonprofit |
We depend on your donations. Support us today.

'A Simple, Practical Solution'

Published: Monday, December 10, 2007 7:29 PM PST



Cities are facing climate change. Urban areas are warming up. Storm water overflow is contaminating beaches, bays, rivers and lakes. Development continues to encroach on the natural environment.

Green roofs (or "eco-roofs") provide a simple, practical solution to all these problems. Green roofs are an engineered, lightweight roofing system that supports plants. Green roof technology has been popular in Europe for 30 years, and is used in some North American cities including New York, Chicago, Toronto, and Portland, Oregon. But green roof technology is not well known in most of the United States and hardly at all in San Diego. 

I planted San Diego's first occupied commercial green roof at my own business in Kearny Mesa this past March. Green roofs offer a number of benefits both to the environment, and to the businesses and residences that install them. Green roofs can prevent water pollution, lower energy use, lower ambient air temperatures, combating the urban heat island effect, clean the air and add oxygen, mitigate the loss of environment, and extend the lifespan of the roof by two or three times.

Perhaps the biggest benefit to avid gardeners is that green roofs provide found space, a place to garden where none previously existed, especially in urban environments. 

Why can't we bring this technology to San Diego and the Western United States and make green roofs successful here? While you might think San Diego provides a perfect environment, our lack of rainfall means we have the challenge of successfully establishing a green roof in an arid region while mitigating the need for excessive irrigation. 

So I'm doing in the hard way, with Southern California native plants for lower water use and maximum environmental benefits. They are planted in 20 yards of custom blended growth media which is spread across the roof to a depth of four inches. 

The cost of an installed green roof is approximately $10 to $25 per square foot. Ours cost roughly $24,000, including a new roof (which was about half the cost). While green roofs typically require a greater initial investment, it is important to keep in mind that they can extend the life of the roof by decades and reduce the heating and cooling costs of your building.

But the real bottom line is this: we have to start getting serious about ways to improve our environment and reverse some of the damage we've done.  When you have children like I do, you start thinking about what we're going to leave behind for the next generation.  A lot of people talk about it.  I'm committed to creating public policy changes that will drive the market for green roof technology in the western United States.

-- JIM MUMFORD




12 Comments so far on this story...

If you are going to be walking around on your roof planting petunias, make sure your homeowner's insurance is adequate (not to mention your personal health insurance). What does Al Gore have planted on his roof?

Posted by Edgar | reply to this comment
December 11, 2007 12:12 am

I'm a fan of green roofs, and they make sense for many reasons. Plants improve the aesthetics of density, so I am looking at changing the state water code to allow the use of reclaimed water on rooftop gardens, to reduce our dependency on imported water for landscaping. Green roofs may also help protect homes from fires, by creating a barrier against falling embers. In meetings with CCDC staff, I have discussed adding green roofs to more downtown buildings to capture runoff, reduce heating & cooling costs for condos and commercial buildings, and provide more park-like spaces on top of buildings for park-starved downtown residents and office workers. As land costs continue to increase, and denser communities are developed, making better use of the "found space" on roofs will make even more economic sense. Lori Saldana, Chair Housing and Community Development Committee California State Assembly

Posted by Assemblymember Lori Saldana | reply to this comment
December 11, 2007 2:55 am

Wouldn't it be wise to advocate green roofs for those who had flat (almost) roofs and safe access to them ? Many people have pitched rooftops and no flat area. Raised patio beds and sturdy patio covers (with access) would be good too. Another use for those same rooftops is solar power, especially when they make it affordable and perfect the thin film technology, which is much less than the cost for PV solar. I agree with the reclaimed water idea for gardening. One of my neighbors was forced by our homeowners association to remove her green roof (it was beautiful) because it was against the homeowners association rules. Ms. Saldana, how about championing a change in homeowners association rules to allow green rooftops ? We need help in that area, those of us who live within the confines of associations.

Posted by San Marcos says, | reply to this comment
December 11, 2007 8:18 am

Nice advertisement.

Posted by Larry | reply to this comment
December 11, 2007 8:39 am

Well, I am all for green roofs. But I am also concerned that rooftop space could be used for solar panels, and that such a use might become more feasible just as green roofs become more popular. I do understand that both can be used at different sites, but what is the opportunity cost of forgoing solar for xeriscaped roof gardens? And as far as San Diego goes, how likely is this to mitigate gigantic, storm-stopping urban heat island created by our dirty power generation, hordes of SUV-driving commuters, snarlingly filthy, regulation-defying industry and general lack of heat- and soot-conscious lifestyles? So every step in the right direction is an improvement... but this one seems to be potentially a little ineffectual. Let the downtownies go without until they learn to commute via mass-transit and put their feet down on the neck of the eco-cynical overdeveloper, the CCDC.

Posted by Frank In SD | reply to this comment
December 11, 2007 9:06 am

Love the green roof idea! CCDC and the City of San Diego should be encouraging builders and building owners to make this kind of investment. Did you get any kind of incentives or support from the City to build your green roof in Kearney Mesa? $10 to $25 per square foot is not cheap for a roof, but if the City can provide some good incentives, lots more people will build them.

Posted by Simple Guy | reply to this comment
December 11, 2007 9:08 am

There is no doubt that Green Roofs has substantial and wide-ranging advantages over traditional roof surfaces. I personally, believe green roofs provide aesthetic, enviromental and economic advantages. By creating a green roof layered with soil and plants atop residences, and businesses you not only add natural beauty to a landscape increasingly dominated by concrete and pavement, you also help reduce the urban "heat island" effect, by which cities tend to be several degrees hotter than surrounding areas, and you provide a roof-garden habitat for insects, songbirds and other wildlife. Green Roofs has become an important part of the new built enviroment, addressing some of the most urgent ecological issues facing our urban centers today. Investing and exploring in green roof technology is an important way to allow our cities to grow and develop while ensuring the protection and and continued vitality of our natural enviroment.

Posted by Angelina | reply to this comment
December 11, 2007 10:28 am

The Clinton Library is installing a green roof according to this Sunday's Union-Tribune. Nice touch that they are planting yellow roses in honor of his mother. I saw a playhouse recently with a green roof. It looked very good and has an environmental lesson embedded for the kids. It seems to me that restaurants should use green roofs to ensure really fresh herbs and veggies for their salads!

Posted by Sandy Fowler | reply to this comment
December 11, 2007 11:15 am

I'll repeat what I basically said before, only failed to get posted because it might have been too harsh in the eyes of the gnomes of VOSD. This time I'll try toning it down: You are all ... a bit odd.

Posted by Edgar | reply to this comment
December 11, 2007 7:02 pm

Frank in SD - when we have the problem of green roofs competing for rooftop real estate with solar, why don't we deal with that problem then? Right not, 99.999% of all rooftop real estate in San Diego is neither green nor solar, it's just asphalt shingles or hot mop tar with a few red clay tiles thrown in for good measure, but overall San Diego roofs are covered with materials not doing anything useful for the environment. It'll be a great day in San Diego when we have to worry about green roofs taking space away from solar power installations!

Posted by Simple Guy | reply to this comment
December 11, 2007 9:59 pm

It sounds like a good idea on the surface, but what about further down in the soil? It seems like there will be insurance issues with roof leaks and repairs, structural issues, etc. And how about maintenance? Even native and drought tolerant plants need to be maintained, are people going to climb on their roof to trim shrubs, repair broken irrigation lines, repair a leaky roof? It seems like the Cons outweigh the Pros on this one, we're trying to reduce green waste and the amount of water we apply to our landscapes. I think solar is a better use of our roof-top real estate.

Posted by Ed | reply to this comment
December 12, 2007 10:52 am

In Germany, where I live, the technology of green roofs has been highly developed during the last twenty years. All the problems that you see have been challanged and more or less solved. We plant exactly the type of plant community that is best for your unique environment and we know how to keep maintenance extremely low.

Posted by Elisabeth | reply to this comment
December 13, 2007 8:23 am


Reader feedback
  • Users may post more than one comment, but should not pose as multiple users. Multiple posts from the same IP address but with a different user name on each will be reviewed to determine whether abuse has occurred.
  • Posts with overly personal attacks or unsubstantiated allegations may be edited or deleted.
  • Please be patient with the posts -- there may be a delay before they appear on the site -- and make sure to enter the code in the "image verification" box.
Post a comment
Name:
Email:
Comments:
Current Word Count: Verification Code
8af5147

Sign Up for Daily and Breaking News Alerts

Don't want to miss a story? Want to be the first to know about breaking news? Sign up now.

This Just In

Preuss Talks to Press:

 Media conference planned by charter school accused of grade-changing. » Dec. 11 -- 12:55 pm



The SEC's Charges:

 Details from the charges against the city's former auditing firm and its owner.

Dec. 11 -- 12:44 pm


Come to San Diego:

 San Diego, or at least the new Hard Rock Hotel, is one of the NYT’s 53 places to go in 2008.

Dec. 11 -- 12:01 pm


MOST POPULAR STORIES:

SURVIVAL IN SAN DIEGO

Dear Great-Aunt Sue... :

  What some of you would tell your relatives about the year we've had in real estate.

Dec. 11 -- 11:38 am



LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

Oceanside Development:

 

Dec. 11 -- 1:52 pm



CAFÉ SAN DIEGO

Wishlist:

  Take a look at what Mayor Richard Daley is up to in Chicago.

Dec. 11 -- 5:03 pm



COMMENTARY: SLOP

How Calderon Emerged :

  A former city official remembers the hiring of an outside auditor for the city that the SEC now says committed fraud.

Dec. 11 -- 4:12 pm



COMMENTARY: RICH TOSCANO

November Home Prices :

  San Diego resale home prices took their biggest hit yet last month.

Dec. 9 -- 6:54 pm


Copyright © 2008 voiceofsandiego.org. All Rights Reserved.