voiceofsandiego.org: Slop... Good Riddance. Really?
an independent nonprofit |
March to 1,000 Members: 991 so far. Contribute today.

Good Riddance. Really?

Published: Tuesday, March 11, 2008 10:29 AM PDT



Is this the end of Luis Acle's political career in San Diego? Who knows, he's gone down before and gotten back up. (Feel free to consult our in-depth profile of Acle for a refresher of the beginning, middle and beginning of the end of his public influence.)

Regardless, I was a little surprised at the heap of crud the Union-Tribune threw on Acle today with a "don't-let-the-door-hit-you-on-the-way-out-you-jerk" editorial.

I mean, this is some shameless stuff.

In a piece titled "Good riddance," the U-T editorial board cried out for new, strong leadership after Acle's demise.

Here's one of the two reasons the U-T gives to justify its outrage with the man now:

Given his checkered financial record, Acle will not be missed. In 2004, a federal tax court ordered him to pay $48,500 in taxes and penalties for unreported income.

Let's see, the court ordered Acle to pay that fine in the summer of 2004. Was the U-T upset then? Nope.

The editorial board endorsed Acle's campaign for the election in November.

Let's look back to Oct. 15, 2004. Again, this is after Acle's tax struggles and strange international dealings came to light. What was the board's take on the presumptive school board leader?

In District D, we favor Luis Acle over Ben Hueso. Born in Mexico City, Acle's life experience should inspire the district's Hispanic students. He came to this country and began to learn English at age 13. He earned degrees from San Diego State University and Stanford and worked his way through a succession of jobs, including a stint in the Reagan administration as an associate director for public liaison in the White House. His no-nonsense approach to education as a substitute teacher in the city schools has had a positive effect on students, especially in alternative schools. As a father of two students at San Diego High School, Acle has a strong interest in the district's reforms succeeding, particularly at the secondary level.

One endorsement wasn't enough. Two weeks later, the editorial board reiterated its strong endorsement of Acle and two other candidates for school board:

The enmity among board members could be eased enormously on Nov. 2 if voters elect Miyo Reff, Luis Acle and Sharon Whitehurst-Payne. They would bring fresh perspectives and a determination to move the district forward. The trio would preserve the parts of Superintendent Alan Bersin's multifaceted reform program that are working, and also make needed corrections to accelerate student achievement.


That's not all. Acle, with not even a year in office, surprised everyone and decided to run for City Council, abandoning his commitment to reform at the district. Who had his back? The U-T editorial board, of course, endorsed his City Council bid.

Acle, president of the San Diego Unified School Board, is capable, in our view, of standing up to the heavy union pressure that seeks to maintain the discredited status quo at City Hall. What's more, he would be a reliable vote to advance Sanders' plans.


Now it's "good riddance?"

Surely they have other reasons for turning on him. Right? The editorial board briefly summarizes the San Diego Ethics Commission complaint against the man. The editorial board has always derided the Ethics Commission and its mission. And they never seemed to care about the investigation into Acle until now.

Acle is a strange public figure with some major problems ahead. His leadership has indeed been questionable. But the U-T waited until he was truly down and out before deciding to kick him.

-- SCOTT LEWIS




10 Comments so far on this story...

This is par for the course at the UT. The left hand forgets what the right one did yesterday. Remember the TOT initiative that was endorsed by the firefighters, hotels, police, labor, and arts community? They said that that initiative was bad because it earmarked too much of the money, taking flexible budget control from the Council. Sounded like a good argument. After the failure of the first initiative, the Council put a "no strings" TOT increase on the ballot, as the UT had suggested. The UT then editorialized that the initiative would give the politicians too much control over the money, and that the public needed to know where it was going. The UT editorial board can't be counted on for consistency, they just blow with the wind. Although I don't always agree with the Voice on their editorials, at least you folks are consistent!

Posted by CBW | reply to this comment
March 11, 2008 12:02 pm

Let's see---who are some elected officials that the U-T editorial board has endorsed enthusiastically (and in some cases multiple times besides Acle? Cunningham, Martinez, Atkins, Maeinschein, Vargas, Madaffer, Peters, Roberts, Stallings, Dumanis, Filner, Wear, etc. All of these named are ethically challenged to varying degrees. Is there little doubt as to which editorial staff, in San Diego, should be writing for Comedy Central? With all the U-T cuts, Bob Kittle and Burl Stiff still survive. I suggest that these two gentlemen switch jobs. Burl's Pearls on the Op-Ed section. Kittle's little Bittles on the snooty nosed society page.

Posted by Torrey Pines | reply to this comment
March 11, 2008 12:37 pm

This is classic U-T. Recall that they endorsed Aguirre. And Duke Cunningham. Their support for Acle was because he'd do Bersin's bidding -- and, for added value in their eyes, he was a former Reagan staffer. What was not to love about the guy back then?

Posted by reader | reply to this comment
March 11, 2008 12:52 pm

Interestingly, Burl Stiff is NOT an employee of the UT but an independent contractor.

Posted by insider | reply to this comment
March 11, 2008 1:18 pm

Insider is right. And there's debate over whether he receives pay or does it for the privilege of breathing the same air as Sally Thornton and Jeanne Jones. Seeing them in their Oscar de la Renta and Reem Acra creations makes life worth living, and for sustenance, he stands near the kitchen door and sneaks a canape from the help!

Posted by reader | reply to this comment
March 11, 2008 1:39 pm

Mike Aguirre. He's perhaps the most despicable of all. Of course, Aguirre was endorsed by the U-T before he was against it.

Posted by Torrey Pines forgot ... | reply to this comment
March 11, 2008 10:15 pm

The good news about all this is that we might get Richard Barrera on the school board! In their editorial, the U-T had one line about him, noting that "the only other candidate in District D is Richard Barrera, a union organizer." Say no more. For them, that's like saying the only other candidate is Satan. The rest of the editorial pleaded for someone else to jump into the race. Anyone who's met Richard knows he would be the best thing to happen to San Diego schools in a long, long time.

Posted by Kensington | reply to this comment
March 12, 2008 7:36 am

My personal favorite factoid about Luis Acle is his recent comment that he likes to engage in public service once every decade or so, that his (free ride) time at the San Diego Unified Board of Education takes care of years 2000-2010, and that he won't seek to appeal the ruling that he lacks sufficient signatures to be on the ballot. In 2004, when Acle also failed to get the requisite signatures, then-Superintendent Alan Bersin had the school district's own lawyer get involved in the appeal for candidate Acle. As for Union-Tribune endorsements, God giveth and God taketh away. They have grudgingly endorsed many liberals, at least once.

Posted by Fed Up | reply to this comment
March 12, 2008 8:36 am

Burl Stiff for mayor---at least we'll know what the movers and shakers are wearing, and how tasty their canapes are.

Posted by Fred | reply to this comment
March 12, 2008 10:34 am

I've known Luis since the sixies, having worked with him when he was a chemist at Teledyne and having kept in contact with him since then. I find him to be a very intelligent, hard working and honest man. He's spoken with me about the problems he incurred with his campaign personnel, and knowing him as long as I have, feel he is being unjustly crucified for what he sincerely believes was not morally wrong. I can only hope that justice will prevail and that he will truly be found to be the man I know him to be. (And I'm a Democrat!!)

Posted by David Rethoret | reply to this comment
July 14, 2008 12:14 pm


Reader feedback
  • Users may post more than one comment, but should not pose as multiple users. Multiple posts from the same IP address but with a different user name on each will be reviewed to determine whether abuse has occurred.
  • Posts with overly personal attacks or unsubstantiated allegations may be edited or deleted.
  • Please be patient with the posts -- there may be a delay before they appear on the site -- and make sure to enter the code in the "image verification" box.
Post a comment
Name:
Email:
Comments:
Current Word Count: Verification Code
50f28e0

Scott Lewis on Politics

The Scott Lewis on Politics blog, abbreviated cleverly as SLOP, is a collection of observations, insights and the occasional scoop on public affairs in San Diego. Please feel free to e-mail Scott at scott.lewis@voiceofsandiego.org.


Listen to voiceofsandiego.org's radio program on AM 600 KOGO: Latest Episode (October 18): Andrew Donohue and Scott Lewis talk in depth about the Chargers stadium search, municipal bankruptcy and whether residents are too dumb to vote on the City Hall project.

Subscribe to the Podcast Feed



MOST POPULAR STORIES:



MOST POPULAR STORIES:


Copyright © 2009 voiceofsandiego.org. All Rights Reserved.