D7 and the Next City Attorney
Published: Thursday, May 1, 2008 11:16 AM PDT
So last night I moderated a well-attended and well-organized debate between the candidates for City Council District 7.
After asking a question about how the perspective council members viewed the role of the city attorney, I decided it would be interesting to see who each of them supported in the tense race to be the city's top lawyer.
Here's how they responded:
April Boling, the certified public accountant and Republican standard-bearer in the race, said she was now comfortable announcing that she endorsed Jan Goldsmith, the superior court judge in the race.
Bill Daniel, the teacher, said he was unwilling to say -- though, he had spoken in very complimentary terms about incumbent City Attorney Mike Aguirre.
David Tos, the police officer, said he too would support Goldsmith. But he was reluctant to talk too much about it because, as a cop, Aguirre was in his "chain of command."
Finally, Marti Emerald, the former television reporter/consumer advocate turned politician, said she was unwilling to say as yet who she supported -- she hasn't decided.
But she did indicate she didn't support Aguirre and, in the past, she has, reportedly, expressed some degree of affinity with Goldsmith as well. Emerald's husband -- attorney S. Myron Klarfeld -- has worked with Goldsmith before.
In a Q&A with San Diego Magazine's Tom Blair a couple of years ago, "San Diego's most visible consumer advocate" touched on the connection:
[Tom Blair]: You married an attorney a couple of years ago.
[Marti Emerald]: Michael Klarfeld. He’s an amazing man. We’re celebrating our fifth wedding anniversary. And he has been my rock.
TB: It has to be helpful in your work to have an attorney at home. Does he ever give you advice?
ME: When does he not? But yes, absolutely, the discussions around our house are very interesting. We met when I was doing a story about a consumer issue. He helped write the law that took expiration dates off gift certificates in California. He sued dozens of major national retailers. Some friends were the lead plaintiffs. And he won the suit. Then he went to his assemblyman at the time, Jan Goldsmith, and said there ought to be a law. And so the two of them sat down and wrote it, and it passed unanimously.
If she does support Goldsmith, that might be a bit interesting. After all, Emerald's friends in the labor community have thrown their lot in with City Councilman Scott Peters and she has already broken with them, passionately, with the question of Proposition C -- the restructuring of the city auditor function (she opposes it, and the Labor Council adamantly supports it).
Reader Feedback
Comments are now displayed with the newest at the bottom. Not sure you're seeing all of the comments? Click here:
Comments so far on this story: 1. Mrs. N wrote on May 1, 2008 12:42 PM: "I would hope boling supports goldsmith.....she is afterall his paid campaign treasurer." 2. rposie wrote on May 1, 2008 3:28 PM: "Boling's client list apparently doesn't sway her. Remember Dick Murphy, Mrs. N?" 3. Dan wrote on May 1, 2008 4:42 PM: "That was an excellent debated hosted by the Tierrasanta Town Council! The candidates left quite a bit to be desired, bobbing and weaving, dipping and dodging....but overall it was decent insight into their quite average and unimpressive brains. Someone from the Tierrasanta Council should run instead. After speaking to some of them, they seemed more informed than the candidates for District 7!" 4. Jon B wrote on May 1, 2008 4:42 PM: "rposie of course we remember Dick Murphy. So should April as she was fined for unethical reporting of $35,000. Talk about a San Diego insider, looking to be more of the same tired thing at city hall." 5. A few thoughts . . . wrote on May 1, 2008 6:06 PM: "Isn't David Tos a San Diego police officer? How is the city attorney in his chain of command. He isn't. Toughen up, Tos. I wonder what Bill Daniel thinks about Pol Pot? Also, if he were to win, doesn't he think he'd like an attorney who would actually give him legal advice, and correct legal advice, so that he doesn't end up like the the Pension Six?" 6. Dale Peterson wrote on May 1, 2008 6:23 PM: "Well, I attended the forum also. Kudos to the moderator (Mr. Lewis) for the pointed follow-up questions designed to knock the fence sitters off of their vanilla perches. Ms. Emerald was asked about the influence of the unions on city politics. The audience was then treated to two plus minutes of nothing about the topic. Ms. Emerald mentioned that she is a bit of a VOSD junkie. So, if she is monitoring this stream, I'd like to invite her to answer that question directly and honestly. At least Mr. Tos and Ms. Boling answered questions with some direct replies. As an occasionally mislead citizen, I like that quality in a candidate--even if I hear something that I disagree with. I'd rather vote for a StraightShooter than a packaged Troubleshooter. And, that viewpoint also applies to candidate Jan Goldsmith." 7. Tierrasanta Tom Tom wrote on May 2, 2008 7:22 AM: "Mrs. N, rposie and Jon B should have provided their union affiliation with their Emerald campaign rhetoric. Maybe their candidate should focus on answering the questions and telling the truth or is that too much to ask from someone who can't remember what her responses were from one meeting to the next? What's Marti going to do if elected - call the Labor Council during the meeting to ask them how to vote or will she do that beforehand? For someone with her background, she has no clue." 8. Eric wrote on May 2, 2008 8:25 AM: "I was an organizer of the candidate forum in Tierrasanta and I would like to thank Scott Lewis for his excellent service as moderator of the event. He did a good job keeping the event moving (12 questions were asked) and he handled the four candidates with fairness. The only downside was he tried hard but failed to get Marti to answer questions that she simply wouldn't answer: she just blathered her way through his persistence, and in the end on several questions she said nothing of relevance." 9. Billy Bob Henry wrote on May 4, 2008 6:28 PM: "I agree with April Boling when it comes to supporting Goldsmith. my real affinity though lies with my support for firefighters, police officers, and Scott Peters" 10. Fred Williams wrote on May 6, 2008 7:39 AM: "I was surprised to hear that Marti Emerald wants the city to subsidize the Chargers...AGAIN. Boling is an insider's insider, but even she doesn't think we should give any more money to billionaire sports-team owners." 11. Joe Baggo wrote on May 7, 2008 2:02 PM: "To a few thoughts. I attended the debate. Marti did skirt around issues not really answering any questions. AB and Tos did and it was refreshing. Your comment however is out of line. Tos, is remotely in Aquirres chain of command. As an officer he enforces misdemeanor crimes. He did support Goldsmith openingly and did not want to go any farther and there was no need. i liked his passion and a vision on we must bring in $ to the city everyone talked about audits and cut backs. He is getting my vote! We need new vision like he said."
Feedback Rules
Users may post more than one comment, but should not pose as multiple users. Multiple posts from the same IP address but with a different user name on each will be reviewed to determine whether abuse has occurred.
Posts with overly personal attacks or unsubstantiated allegations may be edited or deleted.
Please be patient with the posts -- there may be a delay before they appear on the site -- and make sure to enter the code in the "image verification" box.
Add Your Comments
|