A Nerd's Eye View

Case-Shiller Declines Again in January



The Case-Shiller home price index for San Diego was down 2.5 percent in January. This is not as poor a showing as we saw in December, but it's still pretty bad for a single month. From its November 2005 peak, the Case-Shiller index -- the most accurate indicator of aggregate home price movements -- has declined by 21.1 percent.

Kelly Bennett has provided a fairly detailed writeup on the movements of the index's three price tiers, so I won't rehash that here. Once you've read through Kelly's piece, come on back and have a look at the following charts.

The first chart shows the three tiers' declines from their respective peaks. The high tier has clearly held up best, although it has started to decline a lot more steeply in recent months.



The second chart shows price changes in the three tiers back through 1989. This puts the high tier's strength into context, as it becomes clear that high-end home prices didn't rise nearly as much as those of their as their lower-cost brethren during the bull market (this disparity is largely an artifact of the explosion in subprime mortgage credit).

While the low tier has taken the brunt of it, all three price tiers are now declining pretty reliably. This is no surpise considering that in spite of the steep price declines so far, San Diego homes remain substantially overvalued.

-- RICH TOSCANO



Rich Toscano is a financial advisor with Pacific Capital Associates*;
he also writes about San Diego real estate at Piggington's Econo-Almanac. Contact him at rtoscano@pcasd.com.

    Recent Nerd's Eye View Posts

April Housing Supply and Demand

No Spring Rally Just Yet

Employment Sector Winners and Losers

Another Bad Month for Home Prices

BailoutWatch: I Can't Even Keep Up

Employment Goes Negative

A Mixed Month for Foreclosures

Employment's Been Weak for a While

Fence Sitters Will Be Sorry

*Investment advisory services and securities offered through Girard Securities, Inc., member SIPC/FINRA.

NCT vs. Horn, Round II:

 

Horn says the media stinks; newspaper says Supervisor Horn lacks credibility.

Friday, May 9 -- 4:42 pm

Getting Struggling Students Help Earlier:

 

New plan includes targeted help in first, third and eighth grade.

Friday, May 9 -- 2:24 pm

Unions and City at Impasse:

 

The mayor announces that negotiations between the city and three unions have reached an impasse.

Friday, May 9 -- 12:25 pm


Sponsored By

MOST POPULAR STORIES:

SURVIVAL IN SAN DIEGO

Survival Gone Fishin' :

 

It'll be quiet in the blog for a bit.

Wednesday, April 30 -- 9:47 pm

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

Frye: It's the Fox Guarding the Hen House:

 

None of the five largest cities in the United States allow their mayor to appoint the city auditor.

Friday, May 9 -- 2:54 pm

CAFÉ SAN DIEGO

An Uphill Battle :

 

EHC members want to see Barrio Logan redeveloped and improved, but to the benefit of its residents, local businesses and historic cultural heritage. Big developers and speculators have other interests.

Thursday, May 8 -- 4:37 pm

COMMENTARY: SLOP

Quite an Observation:

 

A former fraternity leader speaks out about his old house.

Thursday, May 8 -- 10:38 am

COMMENTARY: RICH TOSCANO

April Housing Supply and Demand :

 

San Diego resale volume picked up considerably last month.

Friday, May 9 -- 10:25 am

Sponsored by

Wall Street's Gates:

 

One important detail to keep in mind.

Friday, May 16, 2008 -- 8:58 am

Dispute Lingers On:

 

Mayor says the unions need to unite behind a pension plan or he's going to the voters.

Thursday, May 15, 2008 -- 6:52 pm

IBWC: Adios, Bajagua:

 

State Department commission says it is scuttling Bajagua.

Thursday, May 15, 2008 -- 2:35 pm

Sponsored By

SURVIVAL IN SAN DIEGO

Foreclosure Flood Continues:

 

Filings up 103 percent over the year.

Wednesday, May 14, 2008 -- 11:33 am

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

Seals vs. People? Why?:

 

Why are we allowing unreasonable people to demand that we spend money to disturb the seal colony that so many people enjoy visiting?

Thursday, May 15, 2008 -- 1:58 pm

CAFÉ SAN DIEGO

'Fresh Face, Strong Voice and a Clear Eye':

 

Marti Emerald can bring all of these assets to City Hall.

Thursday, May 15, 2008 -- 7:50 pm

COMMENTARY: SLOP

Aguirre Bails on TV Debate:

 

'The community knows what I have to offer.'

Thursday, May 15, 2008 -- 6:32 pm

COMMENTARY: RICH TOSCANO

Another Record Month for Foreclosures:

 

Foreclosure filings piled up at their fastest pace yet in April.

Monday, May 12, 2008 -- 11:37 pm

MOST POPULAR STORIES:

Sponsored by


Home About Us Contact Us Copyright Privacy Policy Site Sponsorship
Copyright © 2008 voiceofsandiego.org. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use Privacy Statement