voiceofsandiego.org: Survival... Six Charged in Alleged Mortgage Fraud Ring
an independent nonprofit |
We depend on your donations. Support us today.

Six Charged in Alleged Mortgage Fraud Ring

Published: Thursday, June 19, 2008 4:26 PM PDT



Six individuals were charged in an alleged mortgage fraud scheme with potential losses to mortgage lenders of $5.1 million, the U.S. Attorney's Office announced this afternoon.

The alleged scheme involved 21 properties sold between 2005 and 2006, with at least five in San Diego County and at least three of them condo units in downtown San Diego. The group, operating under the name Creative Financial Solutions Inc., allegedly obtained mortgages for unqualified or unknowing borrowers.

The alleged scheme fits the profile of a common variety of mortgage fraud against lending institutions in San Diego County, often called "cash back at closing." Under the alleged scheme, one of the defendants would contact a listing agent for a property, and offer to buy it for an amount higher than the property's asking price.

The listing agent would raise the asking price and a fraudulently inflated appraisal for the new amount. The lender would approve a loan for the new amount, and the buyer would purchase the house, using a mortgage for 100 percent of the home price or close to it.

The sellers would get their full asking price, and the difference between the original asking price and the new amount would be split in cash between some of the defendants, who acted as agents or loan officers for the purchase. Plus, the defendants allegedly netted commissions on the sales, too.

After the home has been abandoned and foreclosed on, the bank is left with a repossessed property that was never worth the amount the bank had lent.

Of the 21 loans analyzed by the FBI as examples of the alleged scheme, 18 loans have been foreclosed or are in the foreclosure process, according to court documents.

The U.S. attorney alleges that the individuals:

  • Submitted false purchase contracts to conceal the true purchase price of the homes
  • Submitted false loan applications
  • Intentionally concealed the fair market value of the home
  • Used misleading appraisals
  • Submitted false bank statements and income documentation.

    Defendants Abner Betech, Said Betech and Aviva Betech, San Diego residents, were arraigned on felony charges of wire fraud and aiding and abetting on Tuesday. Three named individuals -- Rafael Santiago of Riverside, and Angel Armendariz and Lucette Montane of Chula Vista -- have not yet been arrested. The defendants range in age from 25 to 39.

    The case arose from an FBI nationwide investigation dubbed "Operation Malicious Mortgage," with additional investigation by the IRS.

    Check back for more on this story later.

    -- KELLY BENNETT



  • Sign Up for Daily and Breaking News Alerts

    Don't want to miss a story? Want to be the first to know about breaking news? Sign up now.

    This Just In

    SDG&E Responds to Aguirre:

     A spokeswoman for the energy company responds to the city attorney's lawsuit. » Jun. 19 -- 5:47 pm



    Dianne Jacob on Fire:

     The county supervisor weighs in on her colleague's plan to study controlled burns on county-owned land.

    Jun. 19 -- 5:22 pm


    Aguirre Details SDG&E Suit:

     The city's lawsuit alleges negligence on the energy company's behalf.

    Jun. 19 -- 2:17 pm


    MOST POPULAR STORIES:

    SURVIVAL IN SAN DIEGO

    Six Charged in Alleged Mortgage Fraud Ring :

      Prosecutors say the six defrauded lenders on at least five local properties, including three downtown condos.

    Jun. 19 -- 4:26 pm



    LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

    Something We Can Agree On:

     I rarely agree with Bill Horn. But his idea about controlled burns is one of the only feasible ways to help protect the county from massive wildfires.

    Jun. 19 -- 3:16 pm



    CAFÉ SAN DIEGO

    Out for a Bit:

     Recovering from elections, the Café San Diego staff will be taking some time to get the new schedule together.

    Jun. 17 -- 6:47 pm



    COMMENTARY: SLOP

    Part II: Reality and the Airport:

     Let's drink down their hysterical assumptions for a second and provide a way to deal with them.

    Jun. 19 -- 4:43 pm



    COMMENTARY: RICH TOSCANO

    Prices Way Down, Sales Way Up :

      The most beaten-down neighborhoods are enjoying a resurgence of home sale activity while the more resilient areas stagnate.

    Jun. 17 -- 10:18 pm


    Copyright © 2008 voiceofsandiego.org. All Rights Reserved.