voiceofsandiego.org: Slop... Election 2008 Winners and Losers: The Republican Tigers
an independent nonprofit |
Support This Service

Election 2008 Winners and Losers: The Republican Tigers

Published: Friday, November 7, 2008 7:36 PM PST



So far we've had two winners (the Labor Council and Kevin Faulconer) in our ongoing account of who won and lost in Tuesday's election. Remember, obviously some candidates won, some lost. But for this, the winners are the people who proved their mettle. Or they are the interest groups that are now better off or more powerful after the election. And I'm looking for your participation. Your e-mails so far have helped (there is currently a debate about City Council Donna Frye raging in my inbox -- did she come out stronger after Tuesday? Send your thoughts).

After two winners then, let's talk about some that didn't come out so well Tuesday night.

Losers: The Tigers of the San Diego Republican Party. Who are the Tigers? The actual Republican Party of San Diego, led by Tony Krvaric. The Lincoln Club. And, finally, Coronado Communications, whose consultants -- Duane Dichiara and Jennifer Jacobs -- are like San Diego's representatives of the movement that was supposedly creating a permanent Republican majority nationwide.

The Tigers are so named because they are brutal. They are hunters. They look at the world the way it is -- not the way they want it to be. It's survival of the fittest. They exploit frustrations and divisions hoping that more people end up on their side than the other. But they still believe you can brutalize your opponent from 9 to 5 and have a beer with them at 6 p.m.

Dichiara and Jacobs ran April Boling's campaign in District 7 of the San Diego City Council. The Lincoln Club campaigned on her behalf as well. She lost. They ran Phil Thalheimer's in District 1. The Lincoln Club sent mailers. The club sent so much junk in the mail, in fact, many seem to think that multiple mailers came sometimes in just one day. Yet Thalheimer lost. The two fiery consultants ran the campaigns of two Republican candidates for Chula Vista City Council. The Lincoln Club joined them and flooded Chula Vista homes with angry mailers. One of their council candidates definitely lost. The other race is too close to call.

Dichiara and Jacobs ran Chula Vista City Councilman John McCann's run for state assembly. McCann lost.

In Chula Vista, trying to challenge City Councilman Steve Castaneda's reelection, the Lincoln Club oddly thought it was a good idea to focus on the district attorney's prosecution of Castaneda that ended in his acquittal and made the prosecutors look like imbeciles. Everyone in Chula Vista knew about the trial and knew about his acquittal. Trying to pretend like he was guilty was not going to work and it was simply not fair.

The Republican Party and Lincoln Club miscalculated on nearly all levels (though the Lincoln Club did support Kevin Faulconer and Donna Frye's successful Proposition C).

I asked Dichiara for his thoughts.

He gave me one sentence:

"You can build the best sandcastle on Earth but if a tsunami comes, it's not going to survive," Dichiara said.

But Dichiara did win in District 5, in June. There, Carl DeMaio is poised to take his new City Council seat. He won in the primary and then was able to promptly get to high ground.

-- SCOTT LEWIS




7 Comments so far on this story...

Well I believe D.F. is a big loser after the 4th. Since Aguirre was ousted, Donna will have no one to be a lap dog to. Watch for her to try and find someone elses coattails to hang on to.

Posted by Ron Weiss | reply to this comment
November 8, 2008 8:00 am

Journalists are not very good historians. And, unfortunately, historians these days are behaving like journalists. We need to take a longer view, even of local politics. The GOP did face a tsunami and it wasn't resurgent liberalism. It was an amazing (but deserved) collapse of the credit/debt world, a collapse that is still unfolding. Typically, the last ones to understand the economic environment are those most insulated from it--government. Well, the insulation no longer protects them from the growing heat of the dire economic situation. As the nasty effects reveal themselves in the coming months (years), the incumbents will inherit the political discontents. So, if patient, the GOP will again find their day in the sun, just as the Dems have today. Sadly, given their past track record, I'm not optimistic about either party's ability to deal effectively with our problems.

Posted by josil | reply to this comment
November 8, 2008 12:02 pm

I would hope that the SD Republican Party leaders simply don't lick their wounds by claiming the Obama wind storm knocked the house down. I was a young Republican type at age 16 working phone banks. 30+ years later I see an organization that has abandoned sound fiscal principles. I see a group locally that accepted, condoned, and particpated in financial buffoonery. I see national party leaders that engaged in favoritism for well connected business/lobby interests. Both locally and nationally Republican have become SPEND and REWARD Republicans. Many Republicans just don't care about the moral crusades that the party leaders seem to think are paramount. The fact is the most financially honest and predictable politician in SD, over the last five years, is Donna Frye. In the last sixty days, I received 44 mail pieces supporting Republican candidates. Didn't work!

Posted by Dale Peterson | reply to this comment
November 8, 2008 3:25 pm

Dear Lincoln Club: it was all the Obama tsunami. The Tigers performed brilliantly; the flyers they prepared were absolute masterpieces of the genre. You should not only plan to use them in the future, but you should make sure that in the near term the Coronado Group has enough business so that it is sufficiently capitalized to provide expert advice for at least the next 2 election cycles. I for one am very concerned that the powers that be in Republican party will misinterpret the Boling/Thalheimer losses and some competing, less experienced and less talented political consultants will move into the community. I think the party should move aggressively to maintain the nearly exclusive franchise Coronado Group had this cycle.

Posted by jorgeelgato | reply to this comment
November 9, 2008 10:37 am

I received three or four McCann mailers in one day, on more than one occasion. We received at least one per day for four weeks; most often two per day. That waste turned me off almost as much as the posing with his military uniform and telling me that all laywers are evil, ergo Marty Block is evil (I work for lawyers as an office worker and found this offensive). Hope all Rove-like pols (of all stripes) crash and burn after this election, and we can have respect and statemanship across party lines. Perhaps even the Christian conservatives will start asking themselves HWJR? (How Would Jesus Run?)

Posted by Korinne | reply to this comment
November 10, 2008 9:04 am

The local GOP didn't have a chance after the Bush Recession began to sit in, and voters became aware of the finiancial mess the city's in. The voters blame our problems on the downtown GOP developers and old boys network, and the the GOP candidates in the 1st and 7th districts suffered because of it. It will be interesting to see if Carl DiMaio, San Diego's version of Grover Norquist, will help or hurt the GOP brand next year.

Posted by Watcher | reply to this comment
November 10, 2008 3:10 pm

Bush Recession? You Mean Lamestream Media Democrat commie recession. Obama Cheated, Sheeple Bleated.

Posted by Bill | reply to this comment
November 19, 2008 3:52 pm


Reader feedback
  • Users may post more than one comment, but should not pose as multiple users. Multiple posts from the same IP address but with a different user name on each will be reviewed to determine whether abuse has occurred.
  • Posts with overly personal attacks or unsubstantiated allegations may be edited or deleted.
  • Please be patient with the posts -- there may be a delay before they appear on the site -- and make sure to enter the code in the "image verification" box.
Post a comment
Name:
Email:
Comments:
Current Word Count: Verification Code
f70f3ac

Scott Lewis on Politics

The Scott Lewis on Politics blog, abbreviated cleverly as SLOP, is a collection of observations, insights and the occasional scoop on public affairs in San Diego. Please feel free to e-mail Scott at scott.lewis@voiceofsandiego.org.


Listen to voiceofsandiego.org's radio program on AM 600 KOGO: Latest Episode (November 8): Scott Lewis and Michael Zucchet talk about the city's budget

Subscribe to the Podcast Feed



MOST POPULAR STORIES:



MOST POPULAR STORIES:


Copyright © 2009 voiceofsandiego.org. All Rights Reserved.