A row of zeros stands out on the breakdown of savings estimates from the city of San Diego’s November financial reform ballot measure.

The city, the estimate says, will save nothing from cutting certain pension contributions for unionized employees. The reform calls for the city to reduce the percentage of the employees’ contribution it pays toward their pension, a benefit called an “offset” or “pickup.”

How can a reduction result in zero savings?

Simple. If you give employees something back to make up for taking away the benefit, you save nothing.

The city intends to do just that, said Chief Operating Officer Jay Goldstone.

“It will probably end up being a negotiated trade off for something else they had given up,” Goldstone said.

Most city labor unions eliminated their pickups as part of 6 percent compensation cuts taken by all city employees last year. But the city’s white-collar and lifeguard unions kept the pickups and cut their compensation in other ways.

Goldstone said it wouldn’t be fair to force those employees to take a larger cut than others.

“We’re trying to treat the employees fairly,” he said.

Overall, pickups cost the city about $4.8 million annually from its day-to-day operating budget. That’s not a huge sum in a billion-dollar budget, but it illustrates a bigger point.

If the city gives back some of the savings it achieves through the financial reform package, how does it address its ultimate problem — the $70-plus million ongoing budget deficit?

This reform, Goldstone concedes, doesn’t.

“The other ones do,” he said.

In a larger context, pickups aren’t the only pension giveback the city is considering.

Labor unions are pushing City Council to exclude disability benefits from employees’ pension contributions, which workers now are paying for the first time. Employees paying those costs are saving the city an estimated $2.6 million this year.


    This article relates to: Election, Government, Prop D
    Tags: , , ,

    Stay up-to-date on stories like this. Sign up for a VOSD newsletter.

    Written by Dagny Salas

    Dagny Salas was web editor at Voice of San Diego from 2010 to 2013. She was an investigative fellow at VOSD from 2009 to 2010.


    Log In or Register

    Registered users can follow narratives, comment on articles, check donation history and more.

    If you’ve never logged in before, please create a free account. If you’re a VOSD member, please use the email address associated with your donations.

    Forgot Password?
    New to VOSD? Create an account

    Test Modal
    • Note: You cannot change your username.
    • Minimum length of 8 charactersStrength indicator

    Sign Up For the Morning Report and Top Stories

    Sign Up For the
    VOSD Morning Report

    Get San Diego’s top stories delivered to your inbox each morning.

    To stop this message from appearing, Log in or Register.