U.S. District Court Judge Barry Ted Moskowitz today formally consolidated two separate cases that challenge the constitutionality of a Latin cross on government land atop Mount Soledad and the recent transfer of that land from the city to the federal government.

The cases were brought by Phillip Paulson, the atheist and Vietnam War veteran who has waged a 17-year legal battle to remove the cross, and the American Civil Liberties Union, which is representing a Jewish veterans group and several San Diego citizens.

Moskowitz’s decision was expected. James McElroy, Paulson’s attorney, said the consolidation would only impact his case because now “there are more soldiers in the battle doing the leg work.”

Next week, the judge is expected to announce whether he’ll allow the Pacific Justice Institute, a right-of-center legal defense organization, to join the case as a defendant.

Support Nonprofit Journalism Today

 Learn more about member benefits

All of the parties involved in the case, including the defendants – the city of San Diego and the United States – have asked Moskowitz to deny the institute’s request.

“I would expect that they will not be permitted to intervene based on the judge’s questions,” McElroy said. “They don’t want to fight the legal battle they want to fight the cultural war.”

Several years ago, a state judge refused to let an attorney from the Pacific Justice Institute join another case brought by Paulson. At the time, the attorney was representing former mayor and radio talk show host Roger Hedgecock.


    This article relates to: News

    Written by Voice of San Diego

    VOSD Comment Policy

    Voice of San Diego’s Comment Policy

    If you have any questions about this policy please email info@voiceofsandiego.org. If you have a longer, more thoughtful comment, consider submitting a commentary.


    Sign Up For VOSD’s Free Email Newsletters Today

    Enter your email address below.
    Choose your newsletters:

    To stop this message from appearing for 30 days, Log in. If you’re a current subscriber, you can update your preferences by choosing a new combination.


    San Diego’s Top Stories Delivered to Your Inbox

    Get the FREE daily Morning Report.

    To stop this message from appearing for 30 days, Log in.


    Log In or Register

    Registered users can follow narratives, comment on articles, check donation history and more.

    If you’ve never logged in before, please create a free account. If you’re a VOSD member, please use the email address associated with your donations.

    Forgot Password?