Bill Aimed at Preventing Another Hep A Crisis Has Drawn the Ire of Vaccine Opponents
A bill written by Assemblyman Todd Gloria and Assemblywoman Lorena Gonzalez aimed at preventing a replay of San Diego’s sluggish response to a deadly hepatitis A outbreak doesn’t mention vaccines at all. But it’s facing unexpected backlash from vaccine opponents who believe the bill could compel vaccinations.
Assemblyman Todd Gloria’s legislative effort to prevent a replay of San Diego’s sluggish response to a deadly hepatitis A outbreak is facing unexpected backlash from vaccine opponents who say the measure could compel vaccinations.
Gloria’s office reports it has recently received dozens of daily calls from anti-vaccination activists who fear the bill could give health officials the authority to order immunizations.
AB 262, introduced by Gloria and Assemblywoman Lorena Gonzalez, doesn’t actually mention vaccinations. It aims to clarify public health officers’ responsibilities during outbreaks, including their ability to issue directives to other governments to take action during health scares.
San Diego County officials took months to issue a directive to city officials as the hepatitis A outbreak escalated in 2017, and state auditors highlighted the impact of those delays in a devastating December audit that inspired AB 262.
Advocates have zeroed in on language allowing health officers to order governments to take “any action the health officer deems necessary to control the spread of the communicable disease.”
“We really need California to show up,” Northern California-based activist Denise Marie said last Tuesday in a live video that Facebook reported got more than 5,000 views, one of a handful of late February social media posts that seem to have spurred callers to contact Gloria’s office. “This is a pretty scary bill if they don’t make any amendments to it.”
Denise Marie, who would not share her last name with Voice of San Diego, has since organized a group to rally against AB 262 at the state Capitol on March 19, when the state Assembly’s health committee is set to review the bill.
Gloria spokesman Nick Serrano acknowledged the pushback caught the assemblyman’s team off guard. He said they were focused on the deadly San Diego outbreak and state auditors’ recommendations that the legislators address confusion that may have contributed to the stalled response – not on immunizations.
“We’re not trying to be unreasonable in this,” Serrano said. “We are just trying to make sure that public health is appropriately taken into consideration when we have communicable disease outbreaks.”
But in the days and initial weeks after it was introduced, AB 262 was included on social media-distributed lists of bills across the country that anti-vaccination groups consider concerning.
Late last month, the resistance against AB 262 spiked.
Stefanie Fetzer of Orange County, who runs two Parents United 4 Kids groups on Facebook, shared her concerns in a public Feb. 26 post and suggested followers call Gloria’s office.
Fetzer posted this script on a group page with more than 3,200 followers:
“I am calling to let the Assembly member know that I am opposed to AB262 in its current form. Giving unlimited powers to health authorities in the event of an outbreak is unacceptable. Please enumerate the powers being given to health authorities before moving forward with this bill.”
Fetzer also suggested that activists let Gloria’s office “know we will be calling every day until this bill is amended.”
Dozens shared her post.
Within hours, Denise Marie had also posted her video call to action, and dozens more shared it. Some of their posts spread widely, too.
Fetzer told VOSD she was particularly alarmed after watching a Jan. 25 press conference where County Supervisor Nathan Fletcher, a former state assemblyman who is married to Gonzalez, referenced discussions about potential mass vaccinations during the 2009 swine flu pandemic while answering a reporter’s question about AB 262.
“I don’t think it’s a huge stretch to think vaccines could be included in the powers that are given to the local health authority,” said Fetzer, who has since talked to a Gloria staffer about the bill.
Christina Hildebrand of A Voice For Choice, a group that argues vaccines are linked to autism – a claim that the CDC has expressly shot down – said her organization has separately reached out to Gloria’s office to urge updates and submitted proposed amendment language.
“When you have a such a broad piece of legislation giving broad authority, we’re really just concerned that that can be overreach,” Hildebrand told VOSD.
Hildebrand’s group also came out against SB 277, co-written by Gonzalez and signed by then-Gov. Jerry Brown in 2015, which required that any child enrolled in public or private school as well as daycare to be vaccinated against 10 diseases.
A Voice For Choice unsuccessfully challenged the constitutionality of SB 277 in court.
Both Hildebrand and Fetzer said Gloria’s office has thus far been willing to discuss their concerns about AB 262.
Serrano confirmed that Gloria’s office is considering tweaks but has not committed to changes.
“We will appropriately consider these amendments and hopefully work to find some common ground but (Gloria’s) been clear about what his intent is with this legislation and we’re gonna stay true to that,” Serrano said.
The assemblyman’s goal, Serrano said, is to empower health officers during outbreaks and promote public health.
Clarification: This post has been updated to reflect the fact that SB 277 required vaccinations for children attending private school and daycare in addition to public schools.