Fact Check: The Leanest Police Force in San Diego - Voice of San Diego


Fact Check: The Leanest Police Force in San Diego

The San Diego Police Department has been very vocal recently about its problem with recruiting and retaining officers. But does Chula Vista have it even worse?

TrueStatement: “We unfortunately are among the lowest-staffed police departments in the county,” Chula Vista Mayor Cheryl Cox said at Voice of San Diego’s Let’s Talk Chula Vista event on July 29.

Determination: True

Analysis: Chula Vista Mayor Cheryl Cox is proud of her South Bay city. She wants people to know how safe it is, despite a recent survey showing many San Diegans perceive the city to be dangerous. Cox said at a recent Voice of San Diego event that being ranked as a safe city is quite a feat given the city’s low number of police officers.

“We unfortunately are among the lowest-staffed police departments in the county,” Cox said.

She’s right. Overall, the Chula Vista Police Department has the lowest number of sworn officers per 1,000 residents out of the 10 local police agencies. CVPD had a little less than one officer per 1,000 residents, according to a 2013 SANDAG study. The county average is 1.29 officers per 1,000 residents and the national average is much higher — 2.5 officers per 1,000 people.

You might be surprised that Chula Vista ranks lowest on this list.

The San Diego Police Department has been very vocal recently about its problem with recruiting and retaining officers. An SDPD union official said this week that the department is currently below the number of cops on the street it needs as the bare minimum to patrol the city. In the SANDAG study, SDPD ranked ninth out of 10 county agencies in officers per 1,000 residents. (SDPD says the problem has gotten worse since then.)

CVPD Capt. Gary Ficacci, who has been with the department for almost 25 years, said CVPD’s staffing has gotten worse since the SANDAG study came out, too. The study said the department had 224 officers but Ficacci said the current number is 209.

He said CVPD has always been lean but the staffing issue has been compounded because of budget cuts and retirements by senior officers. The department would like to at least get back to 224 cops, he said.

“If we found 16 qualified candidates, we’d hire them tomorrow,” Ficacci said.

Cox is trying to make a larger point here: Low police staffing can affect the city’s crime rate. But San Diego State University Public Affairs professor Joshua Chanin said comparisons between police staffing and crime is too simplistic.

“Many people would argue more is better,” Chanin said. “To reduce the equation to staffing and crime is improper in a lot of ways.”

Chanin said research on staffing and crime rates is mixed and the two issues aren’t directly correlated. Crime rates, he said, should not be the only factor departments consider when measuring staffing. Chanin said departments should also measure their success based on factors such as community relations with police, whether or not people feel safe in their neighborhoods and if there’s trust and confidence in the department.

While there may be different ways to measure how a thinly spread police staff affects crime rates in a community, it’s indisputable that police departments across the county are facing historic staffing lows. And Chula Vista has the lowest numbers among them.

Show Comments

We’re striving for the best possible discussion and may delete comments using our editorial judgment. All comments containing links will be reviewed by VOSD staff before they are published.
Read our full comment policy.
For longer comments, consider submitting an op-ed to Voice of San Diego.
Read the guidelines here.

We have recently updated our commenting system. If you are unable to submit a comment, please clear the cache and cookies in your browser, or use a private browsing window. Click here for detailed instructions.